generate a new title here, between 50 to 60 characters long
Written on
Identifying Trustworthy Scientific Information
When embarking on a research endeavor or aiming to make informed decisions grounded in solid facts, knowing how to differentiate reliable scientific data from questionable information is crucial. In this guide, I will share my approach as a research scientist to gather credible information that influences my research, teaching, and decision-making processes.
Questioning the Source
It’s common knowledge that not all scientific information available online holds the same level of credibility. While you might recognize that self-published blogs and personal websites are less trustworthy than official sources, such as government agency websites or reputable scientific publishers, it's important to understand that even peer-reviewed scientific literature can vary in reliability.
The Importance of Peer Review
A key indicator of quality is whether an article has undergone peer review. This process is essential in scientific publishing, ensuring that the research meets the rigorous standards of scientific inquiry. Peer review typically involves independent experts assessing the paper, requesting clarifications, and potentially recommending its rejection if the evidence or arguments are inadequate. Most scientific journals will indicate on their websites whether they utilize peer review. Conversely, book chapters and preprints may not undergo thorough peer review and often receive only cursory checks. Preprints, a relatively new form of publication, allow scientists to share their findings prior to completing the lengthy peer review process. While they can provide valuable insights, it’s important to remember that they haven't been independently vetted.
Going a Step Further
Another marker of quality is the publication type. The most trustworthy evidence stems from meta-analyses or systematic reviews. These articles compile data from numerous studies to form a consensus within the scientific community. As scientific understanding evolves, individual studies may present conflicting results, which can arise from random variations or other influencing factors that become evident only when results are compared across different contexts. Meta-analyses offer a comprehensive view of current knowledge and follow established guidelines to minimize biases and enhance synthesis quality. However, given that science progresses rapidly, you might not always find recent meta-analyses addressing your specific inquiry. In such cases, it’s advisable to examine multiple peer-reviewed articles to gain a broader perspective, as relying on a single study can be misleading.
Evaluating the Evidence
In addition to reviewing various papers, it’s essential to assess the strength of the evidence presented in individual studies. The criteria for evaluation may vary depending on the scientific discipline and study type. Many fields adopt an experimental approach, where scientists formulate predictions based on established theories. To gauge a study's quality, consider whether its theoretical foundation is robust and widely accepted. For example, a physics study testing predictions derived from general relativity would have a solid theoretical backing. In contrast, some fields may present more complex evaluations. Pre-registration of studies, similar to registered trials in medicine, serves as a reliability indicator. This practice involves researchers publishing their hypotheses and testing methodologies prior to conducting experiments, reducing the risk of bias from post-hoc interpretations or selective data analysis. A useful guideline to keep in mind is that “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.” This principle suggests that if a claim seems highly improbable, the evidence supporting it must be exceptionally strong. For instance, if someone asserts that their brain training app can elevate everyone's IQ to 150 based on a study of just 10 participants, skepticism is warranted.
Chapter 2: Enhancing Credibility Awareness
The first video titled "Five tips to determine if your source is credible" provides valuable insights into assessing the reliability of sources.
The second video, "How to Find Credible Sources for Research | Finding Reliable Sources," offers practical strategies for locating trustworthy information for your research needs.