# The Trendy Assimilation of Stoicism in Modern Consumer Culture
Written on
Chapter 1: The Rise of Stoicism in Popular Culture
Upon entering the philosophy section of any bookstore, it’s hard to overlook the multitude of titles devoted to Stoicism. A quick online search for "Stoicism and self-help" yields millions of results, some critical of this phenomenon. So, what accounts for the recent surge in Stoicism's popularity, particularly in North America?
Stoicism and the Foundations of Ancient Thought
To grasp this trend, we first need to define "Stoicism." This ancient Greek and Roman school of thought sought to temper the more extreme views of Cynicism. Cynics, disillusioned by the excesses of society, became known for their skepticism toward the motives and potential of the uninformed masses. Their philosophy emphasized simplicity and authenticity, agreeing with Rousseau's assertion that societal pressures corrupt our nature.
Similar to the Beat Generation and the Hippies, Cynics rejected societal conventions, opting for a life free from material constraints. Early Christianity absorbed these ideals, merging them with a longing for a better world.
In contrast, Stoics believed that true happiness arises from virtue rather than the pursuit of wealth, fame, or other external gains. They encouraged understanding nature’s workings and aligning one's actions with natural laws, rather than viewing civilized society as an escape from nature.
Modern advancements have led us to chase relentless progress, creating a false sense of control over nature. Stoics, however, recognize the limitations of this illusion. They perceive possessions not as ultimate goals, but as tools to achieve virtuous ends. The Stoic ideal emphasizes mastering one’s emotions and behaviors, fostering inner tranquility for genuine freedom.
Buddhists extend this philosophy, suggesting that even the notion of self-control can be deceptive. Both traditions advocate for acceptance of our interconnectedness with nature, with Stoics viewing the universe as a deterministic order where our greatest control lies in our perspective.
The Masculine Legacy of Stoicism
Stoicism traditionally promoted a hypermasculine ideal, praising traits such as wisdom, courage, and self-discipline. Ancient philosophers like Aristotle and Plato reinforced patriarchal structures, accepting war and slavery as natural aspects of life. They viewed male superiority as a given, suggesting that societal hierarchies were justified by nature.
Thus, both Cynicism and Stoicism reflect a skepticism about humanity's progressive potential, urging us to seek wisdom in understanding our limitations and avoiding the suffering that arises from arrogance or naive optimism.
Chapter 2: Consumer Culture and the Self-Help Phenomenon
But what is the connection between these philosophical traditions and today’s consumer-driven self-help culture? Is there any value in this modern fascination with Stoicism?
Many of us might be misinterpreting Stoicism to convince ourselves that we are not merely pursuing pleasures, social standing, or material wealth. We might maintain a "daily Stoic journal" as a way to feel wise and in control, even if we consume self-help literature like fast food—casually and without deep reflection.
The unfortunate truth is that those who would benefit most from examining societal values often overlook such opportunities for contemplation. Whether privileged or marginalized, individuals are typically entrenched in their realities, making it difficult to reflect on philosophical questions. Those who truly need to question societal norms often remain unaware, busy with the daily grind of life.
For many, a philosopher's insights may seem irrelevant amidst the demands of family, work, and social expectations. Philosophical exploration can provoke self-doubt and anxiety, leading many to avoid it altogether.
The Ironic Detachment of the Consumer
Nevertheless, the solitary philosopher sees merit in restraining base instincts, even if such musings lead to discomfort. If our relentless pursuit of progress brings about ecological disaster, as depicted in popular media, those who warned against these trends might ultimately find vindication.
Despite experiencing global disruptions, like a pandemic, many continue to trust in the sustainability of our modern societies. Books on Stoicism offer partial solutions, suggesting that while we sense something is off, we fear that engaging deeply with these ideas could be more problematic than beneficial.
As we casually incorporate Stoicism, Buddhism, and Americanized Christianity into our lives, we often dilute their original meanings. This cultural assimilation reflects our preoccupation with societal games, disregarding the potential wisdom these philosophies hold.
The consumer mindset, while retreating inward like a Stoic, often becomes engrossed in fantasies rather than grappling with the harsh realities of existence. The philosopher's alienation from societal norms contrasts sharply with the consumer's reluctance to confront deeper truths.
In recognizing our superficial engagement with philosophy and religion, we should acknowledge that self-help trends often simplify complex ideas. Embracing this reality, the discerning individual can appreciate the fleeting nature of consumer culture instead of pretending to seek a deeper connection.
The first video, titled "How to Be Cool, Calm, and Collected: Stoicism for the Socially Clueless," explores the application of Stoic principles in everyday life. It emphasizes how Stoicism can help individuals navigate social situations with composure and confidence.
The second video, "10 STOIC SECRETS to AVOID THE NOISE of THE MODERN ERA," delves into practical Stoic techniques for maintaining focus and tranquility in a chaotic world. It offers insights into how Stoicism can serve as a counterbalance to contemporary distractions.